Posted by
aurorawatcher on Monday, April 02, 2007 4:13:27 PM
Today we depart from the norm with a guest columnist who is not exactly a guest. Aurorawatcher
Hi, I am BJ, Aurorawater’s husband. She and I collaborate on this blog, but I prefer to work in the background. She’s the writer; I think of myself as her research assistant. But the ongoing debate with badcandie has brought me to step out of the shadows for a moment. You see, badcandie, I used to be a Roman Catholic.
At the risk of imitating Paul in Philippians, I’m going to tell you my Pharisaical history. I am the son, grandson, etc., of Irish Catholics from South Boston, which means my father’s folks are as Catholic as the Pope and probably think they’re even more Catholic than he is. One of my aunts is a nun. My mother was a liturgical Episcopalian when I was born, but she agreed to raise me as Catholic. I was baptized when I was seven days’ old and raised in Sunday school and catechism class. Sister Mary Theodore said I was her best catechism student in 10 years. I was confirmed when I was nine. And, I was a very good Catholic. I really thought that I was eating the body and blood of Jesus when I took communion and I was careful to follow all the forms and practices of Catholicism. I was an altar boy and, like most altar boys, I wanted to be a priest until I discovered girls.
Ah, girls! The downfall of many a good Catholic boy! I discovered girls and beer right the start of high school. It’s my experience that Catholic School students know how to party and Catholic school girls are no more pure than public school girls. And upstate New York in the 1970s was a wealthy neighborhood where parents were gone a lot and we kids could have a good time. A good, sinful time.
I felt guilty about my behavior. I’d grown up going to church every week and I continued to do so. Confession on Saturday afternoon with (we weren’t supposed to know) Father Mac and then communion on Sunday. Except the more I enjoyed my teenage life the less likely I was to make that Sunday morning service. You see, sometimes between confession and communion I would sin and then I was guilty, so I wouldn’t take communion. Father Mac started giving me penitence to do – lots of Hail Marys and Our Fathers – and that would keep me busy for a while, but then my friends would invite me to a kegger and there’d be girls there and … yeah, I wasn’t a good Catholic boy anymore.
This continued after graduation and for the most part I stopped going to church except when I’d get to feeling really guilty. I’d moved to Houston by then, so except for when I saw my dad (who still parties all week and cheats on his wife, but goes to confession on Saturday and communion on Sunday) I didn’t have anyone reminding me that I should do something about feeling guilty. You see, I felt guilty all the time, but I was no longer doing anything about it because I had come to the conclusion that I was on a great hamster wheel from which there was no escape. I would always go back to sinning and I would always feel guilty and I would follow that with confession and I would really do my Hail Marys and Our Fathers, but a lot of times Saturday night would interfere with Sunday morning. It was easier just to have the Saturday nights seven nights a week and not have to do all those Hail Marys (they add up after a while, when you’ve ceased to be a good Catholic, but truly want to be).
My 20th summer, I prayed to God one morning after a particularly sinful night that He would help me find my way out of how I was living. Everything in the world seemed to conspire to prevent me from going to confession the week prior to happenstance putting me in a truck bound for Alaska to work post-Pipeline construction. Not that Alaska is a particularly godly state, but the first person I met in Alaska invited me to church – a non-Catholic church. She was a pretty girl and I wanted to get to know her (leer implied). We agreed that if she came to Catholic church with me, I would go to her church with her. Two things happened on that Sunday. One, she refused to take communion at the Catholic church. She wasn’t mean about it or anything; she just said she didn’t feel right about it and remained in her seat. Afterward, at breakfast, she explained that the whole idea of the bread and the wine actually becoming the body and blood of Jesus felt like paganism to her and she “would not kneel at the altar of another god, even one that bears the same name as Jesus.” That made me angry, but it also impressed me. She KNEW what she believed so much that at a moment of decision with a guy she liked pressuring her, she chose to follow God as she understood Him. I disagreed, but it impressed me.
The second thing that happened that morning was going to her church. I was a little blown away by the simplicity of the place – no statues, stainglass or dramatic paintings -- just a simple cross at the front of the chapel behind a plain wooden table with IN REMEMBRANCE OF ME carved on the apron. On the table was an open Bible. I asked her, is that your altar? She actually had to think about it a moment while I asked “where are the statues?” Having just been to the Catholic church, she knew what that was about and explained that her church didn’t like a lot of distractions from worshipping God and no, that table was the Lord’s Supper table, the altar of God “is in our hearts.”
What can I say – congregational singing sounded awful to the ears of someone used to trained choirs and the preacher was talking about stuff I had never heard before. That the girl I was with could find the scriptures in the Bible impressed me because I had never actually opened one before. The one Bible we’d had when I was growing up sat on the sideboard in the living room and I wasn’t permitted to touch it. It had gilded pages and fancy writing and was large enough to knock a burglar into a coma with, but we never read it. In fact, my stepmother told me that it was sacrilegious to read the Bible for ourselves. The priests would tell us what it meant. The whole church service left me profoundly uncomfortable. They never said anything against the Catholic Church, but it was clear they didn’t worship the same and that seemed as if they were saying something against the Catholic Church. And, they didn’t take communion at the end. Instead, they offered an “invitation” whereby new believers could come up and speak with the preacher. Well, I’d been a Christian my whole life, I didn’t need to speak to a preacher about it.
It turned out the girl wasn’t interested in having sex with me and then I went to the “bush” to work, so I didn’t pursue anything right away. When I came back, I ran into the girl again and she invited me to a Bible study up at the University. I had signed up for classes and so it seemed like something to do. I met Alan, the Baptist Student Union director, and we became friends pretty quickly. He was a few years older, but liked to ski and play the guitar, things I was interested in. It was through him that I began to hear more about Jesus and what the Bible said I should believe.
I could go into a lot of detail, but I won’t. What ended up happening is that I opened that Bible and I started to read the Gospel of John. I didn’t get lucky with this selection. That girl I liked suggested it the same day that Alan suggested it and I took it to be a sign. I was still certain that the Catholic Church was the right church, that these good people I had met were sincerely deceived and that eventually, if I asked enough questions and argued enough, they’d come around. The problem with that was they answered my questions and instead of arguing, they showed me what the Bible said. At one point, I returned to the Catholic Church and confessed my sins. I realized that I hadn’t been out partying since I came back from the “bush”, but the priest was more concerned that I was going to non-Catholic Bible studies. As he gave me more Hail Marys to do than I’d ever been given for fornicating, I suddenly realized that I didn’t feel at all guilty about my foray into non-Catholic studies. I did, however, feel guilty about the last six years of debauchery. Why did I still feel guilty about those when I had said a truckload of rosaries and even helped my dad reroof one of the parish buildings for free? Weren’t those sins forgiven? Apparently not because I felt guilty, but now the priest told me I was even more guilty for reading the Bible than I had been for fornicating and getting drunk. Something didn’t seem right about that. It bothered me so much I couldn’t say the rosary.
That evening, I told Alan that and he told me that the answer to guilt was not saying the same ritualistic prayer over and over again, but turning my heart over to Jesus. I didn’t that night (I went home and started my rosary penitence), but the seed had been planted. I returned to that church the girl had taken me to previously and I listened to the pastor preaching. I started trying to find the passages he was talking about and trying to figure out what they meant. More and more I felt like I had been wrong – off on a pathway that didn’t make sense – for most of my life. Then, one Sunday evening, the pastor gave an invitation. He didn’t usually do that since Sunday evening in the winter was usually church members and he later told me that he had simply obeyed God’s strong urging to do so. There was no music to hide the sound of my cowboy boots on the hardwood floor or my whisper to the pastor that I wanted to accept Jesus as my Savior, but I’d already moved before I realized that this was unusual. I remember the sound of my steps echoing off the ceiling and thinking everybody could hear me (which they could) as I spoke with the pastor, but you know what, I didn’t care. I wanted to be right with God and I knew that the rosary hadn’t done the trick and I’d said A LOT of them over the last six years.
I’ve given a lot of thought about what happened when I accepted Christ. For the first 21 years of my life, I had been operating according to a system my parents had chosen for me. It was a system that set up a lot of obstacles between me and God, between me and Jesus, but the rituals were very comforting. I trusted, because I had been taught to trust, that my baptism when I was seven days old would protect me from going to Hell so long as I remained a good Catholic. And, I tried. I really wanted to be a praise-worthy altar boy, though I think I really wanted that more to have the praise of the priest rather than any devotion to God. We humans are born with a natural tendency toward sin and when I hit my adolescence, I stopped being innocent and started wanting to do what my flesh wanted to do. And, as soon as I started willfully sinning, the Catholic Church could not offer me what I needed. It could offer me works that I could perform to salve my guilt, but it couldn’t heal the damage I was doing to my soul. All that ever happened in the confessional was the priest listening to what I said, asking for details, then getting embarrassed if I gave them, and then he’d give me so many rosaries to do and absolve me of my sin. If he was actually washing them away, why did I still feel them? I’d go out and do my Hail Marys and Our Fathers until I was in a trance and then, when I was done, I feel better for five minutes until a friend would drop by with a six-pack or a pretty girl would cross my path. Then I was back on the hamster wheel again.
The day I accepted Christ, I was freed from my sins. They were buried with Jesus, gone from me for good. I haven’t said a Hail Mary since October 21, 1983, the night I walked that aisle. That night, to me, Mary, the mother of Jesus, became a dead woman with an illustrious past and I recognized immediately that she had nothing to offer me. It’s not her fault; she’s dead and the dead have nothing to do with the living (Luke 16). I haven’t prayed to a saint since then either because dead men and women have no power to affect the lives of the living. I do a lot of praying, but I direct my prayers to Someone alive. Every day and in every way, I walk with Jesus, Who is as alive today as He was 2000 years ago. When I do good works, it is because I love Jesus; not because I strive to win His favor, but because I already have His favor. Rather than go to a child molester to confess my sins (and I later found out I did), I go directly to my Creator and Savior. Although there are many men and women of God whom I admire, I put my trust of salvation only in Jesus. Human beings make mistakes and have bad days. Jesus doesn’t. This doesn’t mean I’m perfect. I still sin and I still must confess my sins, but I now confess them to Jesus and when I’ve done that, they’re actually gone; not just salved.
Catholicism as I experienced it was a religion of forms and rules and rituals. I truly believed it, but it was truly only skin deep. Christianity is a faith that requires conscious contact with God through Jesus Christ and informs my lifestyle. Rather than working on my outside to try to reform my behavior, it wells up from inside me so that my behavior is automatically better than it would be.
And, that’s really the difference between the religion of Catholicism and the faith of Christianity. One is an outward system that our parents choose for us and the other is an inward relationship that our Savior died to give us.
That's why I am not a Catholic any more! Once Jesus lived in my heart, I didn't need a priest to tell me how to live. I understand totally what Paul meant in Philippians 3:12-14 -- "Not that I have already reached the goal or am already fully mature, but I make every effort to take hold of it because I also have been taken hold of by Christ Jesus. Brothers, I do not consider myself to have taken hold of it. But one thing I do: forgetting what is behind and reaching forward to what is ahead, I pursue as my goal the prize promised by God's heavenly call in Christ Jesus."
Badcandie, there is absolutely nothing you can write to convince me otherwise. If I had died a Roman Catholic, my soul would have gone to Hell because Catholicism was all about me doing the right things to go to heaven and I – my sinful nature -- was the problem. Roman Catholicism is about dead men trying to raise themselves from the dead. Dead things can't give life. What I needed was for Someone alive to call me to life and that is all about Jesus doing it. His sacrifice is more than sufficient to wipe away my sins and that requires nothing of me more than just accepting that He’d done it. Jesus’ salvation is the only reason why I am bound for Heaven today. Many will call “Lord, Lord,” on the last day, and Jesus will answer “Sorry, but I don’t know you.” I would have been one of those 23 years ago, no matter how many rosaries I’d said that day or in the past. My faith was in forms and rituals, not in Jesus Christ. Now that my faith is in Jesus Christ, the forms and rituals are no longer of any use to me. In this, I imitate Paul who left behind the forms and rituals of Judaism to follow Jesus Christ.
I know a few Roman Catholics who I consider to be Christians, but in all cases, they recognize that someone can come to Christ apart from the Catholic Church. Their faith is in Jesus, not in the Church, and that makes all the difference. So, I wish you luck and I hope you’ll run into someone like my friend Alan or hear a preacher who is open to God’s leading even when the call is out of the ordinary. As long as your faith is in the Catholic Church, however, you’re very likely going to miss Jesus when He knocks on your heart’s door because Jesus never was a Catholic and it is my experience that Catholics always expect Him to be. They usually demand Him to be and they send Him away until He meets their expectations, which means they never give Him a chance. I hope you're not one of those, but your posts read like that. I’ll be praying for you!