Posted by
aurorawatcher on Thursday, May 28, 2009 2:40:09 AM
I think it must be some pernicious sort of heresy that teaches folks that Christians never doubt their salvation. This is nonsense! Many, if not most Christians, have episodes of doubt, sometimes even severe doubt. It comes with the territory of believing something that isn't rock-solid. Faith is about believing the little bit of evidence we see for the greater reality beyond what our senses can process. Of course, that's going to engender doubt from time to time. Fortunately, God has provided us with diverse means to judge our salvation and the truth of His words to us. Writing to a group of churches that had been besieged by heretics, John addressed doubts concerning salvation because he knew that fear that one is not a Christian is common among church people, particularly those who have been told they may not have the "full" gospel on their side.
All throughout 1John the apostle emphasized the marks of a true believer, enabling us to evaluate our own salvation and those around us. It was critical then and still remains that we be able to identify those who are not real among the crowd who are real Christians, but we must first examine our own hearts to assure that we are Christians.
"Little children, let us not love with word or with tongue but in deed and truth. And by this we will know that we are of the truth and will convince our conscience in his presence, that if our conscience condemns us, that God is greater than our conscience and knows all things. Dear friends, if our conscience does not condemn us, we have confidence in the presence of God, and whatever we ask we receive from him, because we keep his commandments and do the things that are pleasing to him. Now this is his commandment: that we believe in the name of his Son Jesus Christ and love one another, just as he gave us the commandment. And the person who keeps his commandments reside in God, and God in him. Now by this we know that God resides in us: by the Spirit he has given us." 1John 3:18-24
First, we must recognize that love is not an emotion or a word. It's an action. Love is not really love unless it affects someone else. However, love is also not love if it affects someone else for phony reasons. We are to love in action that is truthful and honest.
This sort of love will assure us that we are Christians. Such knowledge, however, is not necessarily intuitive. The phrase "We shall know" is from the Greek ginosko which is a future tense meaning "to know, to learn, to realize." Therfore, this knowledge of love is something we discover. As we experience it, we learn that we are of the truth. How do we come to know this reality? The simplest way is to start with the Word of God, Scripture, the Bible as it talks about the Truth incarnate, Jesus Christ. Christians are people of the Book. The truth has given us life and defines our existence. This grasp of the truth should fill us with assurance (Gr. peitho, meaning to persuade). Our relationship with the Truth incarnate persuades us that we are of the truth. That Greek word peitho has a connotation of persuasion that calms or pacifies a troubled heart. Our fears and doubt recede as we stand in the presence of God. The Bible and our salvation relationship with Jesus tells us that we are linked to the truth, which should completely pacify our fears and doubts and assure our hearts as we stand before God, Who knows everything about us.
How intimidating is that! The character of God is a frightening prospect! Read through the Old Testament. Wherever you see God exercising His character before the people of Israel, you see fear. People were overwhelmingly traumatized when God was in their presence because of His great holiness and righteousness. His perfection only served to highlight their sins in stark relief. Yet, we see the apostles and know in our own Christian lives that we have been turned from the path of unbroken, unrepentant sin to pursue holiness and righteousness. That we still have sin in our lives (mortal flesh is so weak!) causes us anxiety when we think of standing before God, yet John assured us that we will know that we are connected to the truth and that should pacify our fears even as we stand before God.
What an incredible promise!
I hang out with some Christians who believe that you can lose your salvation. It's important to address this belief because our entire discussion in 1John hinges upon that concept. Is salvation revokable? This brings the question -- what is the point of spending our time trying to develop an understanding of assurance if we really have no right to any assurance because our salvation is revokable?
Is eternal life really eternal? Is it possible to repent of your final destination, be headed toward heaven and do an about-face to head toward hell? Can you lose your salvation?
There are those who will submit that possessing a sense of assurance in salvation is presumptuous, even arrogant. You have no right to it because it doesn't exist. The Roman Catholic Church, for example, does not hold that anyone can have assurance of salvation. The RCC believes that assurance is an undesirable confidence that will make you careless about your sin and that carelessness will cause you to lose your salvation. My husband BJ, who was raised Catholic, calls this the "doctrine of mystification". If you're mystified about your salvation, you'll work harder in fear that you might not have it. (See the canons and decrees of the Council of Trent for the RCC official word on this). It's not, in all fairness, only the Catholics who believe this. My more Arminian-minded Christian friends also believe that you can sin so as to forfeit your salvation.
I find these theological perspectives frightening. If I have to keep myself saved by my works, then I'm standing on a slippery slope and I'm not sure there's a means of escape. Where's the joy in that sort of salvation? I don't know. What I do know is that Scripture is absolutely clear on the necessity of assurance for the purpose of enjoying your salvation and praising God (Hebrews 6:11; 2Peter 1:10). My praise of God is directly connected to the eternal nature of His gift of salvation to me. I believe assurance is crucial to Christian living. I have never met a productive Christian sold out to Jesus Christ who was in deep doubt of his/her salvation. If you doubt your salvation to that persistent level, you've got a problem with God's promises and your energy is likely going to be sucked away by fear, doubt and despair.
God is not a dishonest businessman Who includes fine print in His covenant. There is no escape clause for God (John 5:24, 6:27-37; Romans 8:28) in His contract with the human race. The Scripture is clear that God continues what He started and that all He has claimed as His own will be with Him in the end. The Father draws, the Father gives, the Son receives, the Son keeps, the Son raises (John 4). There is nothing temporary about what God has promised Christians. When you were born again, hope came alive in your. God is able to keep you from stumbling (Jude 24; 1Thessalonians 5:23).
There's an older Christian contemporary song where a man asks God about his sin and God replies "What sin?" Our sin has been paid for and we have total assurance of that according to Scripture. How can God hold sin against us that He has promised not to remember?
I am convinced that the question of eternal salvation is not legitimately debatable. It's not really arguable. Salvation is an eternal gift. On the basis of the fact that if you have it you have it forever. Having a secure salvation is a fact. It's not debatable. Feeling secure is something else. There are a lot of Christians who have eternal salvation but they don't enjoy it because they don't think they have it. They think they can lose it, so they live in dread and fear of some salvation-killing sin or demon-theft. They think God is like us with a short attention span. God is eternal; salvation is forever (Isaiah 32:17).
It should be noted, however, that doubt is not necessarily evidence of a lack of salvation. In fact, some of the most assured people don't deserve their certainty. There are lots of people who have walked aisles or raised their hands in a meeting and think that makes them saved. Your heart and mind must accompany your body down that aisle. Salvation is not a magic-words ceremony that you perform. It's a transforming experience of giving your life to God. Oddly, it's my experience that those who struggle with assurance, like those John was writing to, are almost always Christains because they're self-aware of their sin, whereas non-Christians are not. They figure they're good people or they did some ritual as a child and therefore, they've got their fire insurance. What's a little sin now and then? It's the true believer, self-aware of his sin, who struggles with assurance and worries that sin might somehow tarnish salvation to the point of being lost.
Some people mistakenly think that the theme of 1John is that God is love, but the actual theme is assurance of salvation. The Christians John wrote to had had their assurance shaken. The Gnostics said they weren't "full gospel" Christians because they didn't have the secret esoteric knowledge the Gnostics were claiming. John wrote to assure them that they were Christians, that they could test their Christianity and that they could test the Christianity of their opponents. Verse 19 explained that John wrote so that his audience would know they were of the truth, which would make their joy complete (verse 4). Knowing that you have eternal life, possessing assurance is necessary to complete joy. You cannot fully enjoy your salvation without the confidence that it is really yours (Ephesians 3:12; Hebrews 6:19; Colossians 2:2; Philippians 1:6; 2Timothy 4:18)
All Scriptural evidence indicates that God doesn't expect us to go through our lives worrying and wondering about whether we really belong to Him. There are theologies and teachers who teach otherwise, but they cannot do so on Scriptural grounds. Once God saves you, it is forever. Eternal life is eternal life. It is permanent. If you ever had it, you always have it. The work of Christ was complete to the point where there is no way you can forfeit salvation. That would undermine the efficacy and the completeness of the work of Christ. If His work was not sufficient to hold you, then it would be a deficient work. The intercessory work of Jesus at the right hand of the Father makes sure that no successful accusation is ever brought before the throne of God against a Christian. The work of the Holy Spirit also guarantees the eternal life of Christians. The Holy Spirit is the down payment (Gr. arrabon, meaning engagement gift) that will keep you until the day you see the Lord.
Eternal life is meant to be enjoyed now because we possess it now. We need not live in fear of losing it. Satan cannot come along and steal your salvation.That's not what God wants us to do, He wants us to enjoy the security that we have by being sure we are His.
As I mentioned before, it is very rare to meet a non-Christian struggling iwth a lack of assurance. Almost always, it's Christians who struggle with the question of assurance. Sometimes this is because they're steeped in preach about God's holy standard. Old-style evangelical churches tend to emphasize that standard while new-fangled "seeker oriented" churches sometimes downplay that, offering a minimalist kind of gospel that treats salvation as a magic-words ceremony. In those type of churches, people rarely question their salvation because they're rarely confronted about where they measure against God's holy standard. In churches where the holy standard is emphasized, you find quite a few people who at least some of the time question their own salvation. It's the duty of a preacher to create anxious hearts (2Corinthians 13:5). It is sad that so many do not do so.
Perhaps they lack in that area because they are aware of the second reason people might lack assurance. Some people have difficulty with forgiveness. They just can't accept it. There's too much garbae in the minds; too much sin they feel they can't get rid of.
I heard this story from an old Ozark preacher. There was a man, a non-Christian, who shared with a preacher that he had so many sins that he couldn't count them all, so he didn't think God would accept him. The preacher suggested that everytime he felt that he had committed a sin, he should hammer a nail into the barn door. A bit later, the man returned and said the door was full of nails. The preacher then said he would understand the forgiveness of God if he thought of it as pulling all the nails out. The man, grasping this analogy, became a Christian. The preacher suggested that now, everytime he did something in his life that was spiritually worthwhile, he go pull out one nail. Eventually, the man reported that all the nails were out and the preacher exclaimed that was wonderful. "Not really," the man said. "The holes are still there."
Some people never get over the holes, which we can identify as the scars of the past. The conscience speaks against forgiveness. It is the essence of conscience to accuse us, to hold us before the standard of God's perfection and find us wanting. Your conscience is not designed to mollify you and it does not go away when you become a Christian. In fact, it functions better after you've been saved than before because, the Bible says, it was purged and purified. It's clean now and its function is to waken your heart to sin. It will never let you off the hook because conscience knows nothing of forgiveness or mercy. The more you're exposed to the preaching of the Word of God, the more you're exposed to the Law of God, the more you know about sin, the more active your conscience is and the more your conscience berates you in a relentless fashion and yields nothing to the issue of forgiveness, the more possible it is for you to feel the loss of assurance.
Oddly, the way to get around this is to go through it. Let the Law do its work. It is a schoolmaster to drive us to Christ. Let conscience do its work to prevent us from sin by inducing pain over iniquity. Let the justice of God do its work to make us thankful for forgiveness and grace. Both strong preaching of the holiness of God and the requirements that He lays before us and the refusal to accept forgiveness cause people to have a lack of assurance.
Bad theology concerning the gospel and the plan of salvation contributes to a lack of assurance. If you believe you can lose your salvation, then, of course, you can't enjoy assurance. Somehow the whole reality of grace, mercy and forgiveness in Christ is not comprehended by some people. People do not understand the wonder and glory of justification. Most people sitting in most churches who think they're Christians don't even understand the doctrine of justification that is inherently to the gospel. They have had emotional experiences and come to Christ in a measure of faith. They prayed a prayer and experienced feelings of well-being. No matter how vivid, passionate and powerful feelings are at the moment of a magic-words ceremony, emotion is no safe storehouse for your assurance. Your assurance cannot be based upon an emotional experience, it has to be built on a true understanding of the saving work of Jesus Christ. I think many people people hold on to some kind of experience as the evidence of their salvation rather than a true and deep understanding of justification. Do you understand what really happened when God saved you? Do you understand that you were a sinner and God knew it? You were condemned by Him as a just, righteous and holy Judge. Do you understand that that penalty had to be paid and God substituted His Son to pay the penalty that His wrath required? He paid it in full and God was so satisfied with the Son for the payment, that He raised Him from the dead and exalted Him to His right hand and gave Him the name Lord, which is above every name. Do you understand that the work of Jesus Christ was complete? That sin was fully paid for when He died; He bore the punishment for all your sins. And when you put your trust in Him, God credits all His righteousness to your account and God Himself will never remember them again. You won't forget, but He does. Do you understand that?
Assurance then, not an emotional experience, it's a rational reality. I feel sure of my salvation because I understand the work of God in Christ. It's not a matter of holding onto my assurance emotionally. I hold onto it doctrinally. It's facts revealed in Scripture, historical realities in the Bible. It's not a feeling (Romans 8:38). Therefore I enjoy my assurance because Christ has guaranteed it to me, having become the perfect substitute Who paid the price for all my sins. That is the heart and soul of our assurance.